Under article 101 tfeu in the context of a merger process by exchanging. The competition act 1998 and the enterprise act 2002 are the most important statutes for cases with a purely national dimension. Tuesday 23 april 10 am tutorial room 8 tuesday 23 april 5 pm tutorial room 8 friday 26 april 9 am tutorial room 7 bclbbl students. Moldova benefited, in the drafting of this law and of its first state aid law of the technical assistance provided by the competition agencies from romania, austria and latvia. It concerns hard core restrictions of competition like cartels as much as efficiency enhancing agreements. In relation to article 101 tfeu, franchising agreements are subject to the same regulations as other types of agreements and can therefore also be deemed to be restrictive of competition. The gc took the next step in power cables, decided in july 2018. It focuses on chapter i of the competition act 1998 ca98, 1 the uk equivalent of article 101 tfeu. Treaty on the functioning of the european union tfeu. Therefore, if there is a possibility of trade moving across borders then this will be sufficient enough to fall within the ambit of article 101.
As of november 28, 2016, the federal trade commission ftc has expanded the filing obligations under the hartscottrodino hsr act by requiring filers to submit certain documents analyzing a deal or affected markets even where the evaluation or analysis is limited to geographies or operations outside of the united states. Eu competition law rules applicable to merger control european. Critically discuss how eu law as applied under article 101. Market failures, transaction costs and article 1011 tfeu.
Its core role is the regulation of monopolies, which restrict competition in private industry and. Important provisions a treaty on the functioning of the european union tfeu article 101 tfeu. Article 101 tfeu, notion of undertaking and succession of. Articles 101 to 109 of the treaty on the functioning of the european union tfeu contain rules on competition in the internal market, prohibiting anticompetitive agreements between undertakings. Vertical agreement agreement or concerted practice entered into between two or more. Market integration is an objective of article 101 tfeu. Mar 21, 2010 consolidated version of the treaty on the functioning of the european union part three.
Exemptions article 101 provides what is known as a legal exception system. The counterfactual method can be used to assess the effects of an actual event. Companies cannot abuse a dominant position in a particular market to squeeze out smaller competitors article 102 tfeu. A commentary on article 101 tfeu by rick busscher, martin. Capability vs likelihood in the context of articles 101 and. Chris townley, article 101 tfeu and public policy, hart publishing, 2009. Eu competition law ii abuse of a dominant position. Art 101 tfeu however, article 101 3 tfeu provides certain criteria for exemption from article 101 1 tfeu, where an agreement results in procompetitive efficiencies which outweigh its anticompetitive effects. Article 101, 102 formerly articles 81 and 82 and before that. Its purpose is to control anticompetitive behaviour entered into between different undertakings.
These guidelines set out the principles for the assessment under article 101 of the treaty on the functioning of the european union 1 article 101 of agreements between undertakings, decisions by associations of undertakings and concerted practices collectively referred to as agreements pertaining to horizontal cooperation. Article 10 of the treaty on the functioning of the. Download pdf printer dopdf from one of the locations provided and create pdf files for free. In this paper it will discuss the general framework of both articles by analyzing all the elements of the articles, such us. Dec 09, 2014 if rulings like intel and previous ones like michelin ii and british airways are contested, this is so because they are difficult to reconcile with other judgments addressing the same or comparable issues. Client alert antitrustcompetition ecj clarifies the. The basic competition rules are now article 101 replacing article 81 on anticompetitive agreements and article 102 replacing article 82 on abuse of dominance. See, for example, the commissions article 10 guidelines, the cfis recent glaxo case and certain academic works, such as okeoghene odudu, the boundaries of ec competition law. The term counterfactual refers to the hypothetical situation in which merger could not take place. However, if the effect of a business conduct would reach across borders, the european commission has competence to deal with the problems, and exclusively eu law would apply. Application of eu competition rules in the transport. Article 101 of the treaty on the functioning of the european. Expensive and damaging antitrust tripups multinational counsel boot camp june 16, 2015 rachael s.
First, the case law on, respectively, article 101 and 102 tfeu is based on mutually incompatible premises. Agreements that restrict competition by object under article 101 1 tfeu. Treaty on the functioning of the european union and. Council of articles 101 and 102 tfeu, incorporating the corresponding provisions of regulation no 12003 in domestic law. Eu state aid law is now governed by articles 107 and 108 of the tfeu replacing articles 87 and 88, respectively. The prohibition covers all types of behaviour, horizontal or. Describing the law in its economics and market context, the chapters particularly consider the competition law implications of business phenomena, including distribution. The main aim of article 101 is to provide redress to those affected by any restrictions that are placed on free competition within the internal market. Where market share rises above 35% an exemption can remain for one year only. Article 102 and article 101 tfeu have been used as a means of controlling mergers, their usefulness in this context has now been to a large extent overtaken by the merger control regulation.
Article 101 of the treaty on the functioning of the. Article 101 tfeu is one of the most prominent treaty. An overview of the eu competition rules this type may nevertheless be compatible with the competition rules either because they fall outside the scope of the article 1011 prohibition or because they meet the exemption criteria of article 10 see. However, this paper will be narrowed and deal only with horizontal mergers. Suspensory effects of merger notifications and gun jumping oecd.
However where market share rises above 30% but below 35% an exemption can remain for two consecutive years only. Based on article 101 of tfeu the commission has these tasks 22. Jul 11, 2012 treaty on the functioning of the european union tfeu article 101. The first provision is article 101 tfeu, which deals with cartels and restrictive vertical agreements. The main aim of article 101 is to provide redress to those affected by any restrictions that are placed on. The investigation stemmed from a complaint filed by agenzia regionale centrale acquisti arca a public entity owned by the italian region lombardy, entrusted to collate invitations made by pharmaceutical companies for medicines supply. Carriers are therefore required to assess whether their cooperation agreements are compliant with article 101 tfeu. With this case, the commission suggests that it may investigate information exchange occurring. Oct 28, 2011 once the restriction is proven, a defendant company can justify its restrictive practices under 101 3 tfeu by satisfying a fourcondition test. Pdf the concept of agreement under article 101 tfeu.
Common rules on competition, taxation and approximation of laws chapter 1. As a result, agreements aimed at partitioning national markets are in principle restrictive of competition by object. The book explains the purpose of competition policy, introduces the reader to key concepts and techniques in competition law and provides insights into the numerous different issues that arise when analysing market behaviour. Article 102 tfeu case law commission guidance on enforcement priorities 2009. Article 14 ex article 16 tec without prejudice to article 4 of the treaty on european union or to articles 93, 106 and 107 of this treaty, and given the place occupied by services of general economic interest in the shared values of the union as well as their role in promoting social and territorial cohesion, the union and the. After that the first and third paragraph of article 101 tfeu will be discussed on the basis of the courts interpretation as well as the decisional practice of and guidance by the commission. There is no presumption that a threshold over 30% infringes article 101 1 nor leads to failure under article 101 3. Rules applying to undertakings article 101 ex article 81 tec official journal 115.
How does article 10 tfeu case law relate to ec guidelines. Commission regulation eu no 3302010 of 20 april 2010 on the application of article 10 of the. Common rules on competition, taxation and approximation of laws. A critical analysis posted on july 11, 2012 by john dudovskiy each business entity operating within the european union eu is bound to operate within the boundaries of legislation issued by the government of the home country of the business, as well as, the rules and.
Colomo, article 101 tfeu and market integration, 2016 12 journal. The prohibition of an abuse of a dominant position art. In addition, article 106 tfeu ensures that competition rules are equally applied in the specific cases of companies owned by member states or companies to which member states granted special or. Apr 05, 2016 in this paper we will first discuss the general framework of article 101 and the preliminaries of its application. For article 10 object effect is not relevant by their very nature have the potential of restricting competition not referring to parties subjective intentions price fixing, article 1011a vertical glaxosmithkline or horizontal british airways virgin. As prescribed in the merger agreement, immediately after signing, kpmg dk put in a notice to terminate its cooperation agreement with. Eu competition law rules applicable to merger control. The drafters of one amending treaty to the treaty of rome, the treaty of amsterdam, decided it was necessary to renumber the two articles 81 and 82 from 85 and 86. For the history of merger regulation in the eu, see jones and sufrin, above, n. A case commentary explains eu competition law by presenting the relevant legal provisions together with carefully selected case extracts pertaining to those provisions.
The selection is based on the interpretative value of the extracts and is limited to the essentials in order to clearly demonstrate how competition. In its notice on the application of the article 81 3 ec 2004, now article 101 3 tfeu, the commission includes the statement that. Counterfactuals are discussed under article 101 guidelines and article 102 guidance paper of tfeu. Basic concepts and case studies nicolas petit university of liege 11 july 2011 summer program in eu and. Iv, issue 8 november 2016 6945 articles 101 and 102 tfeu are the most prominent treaty provisions on competition. They may meet the criteria for exemption specified in article 10 where they have pro. Article 101 1 tfeu prohibits agreements the object or effect of which is to restrict competition.
The dogmatic of article 101 tfeu and information exchanges. Ncas and the domestic courts are able not only to apply the article 1011 prohibition on anticompetitive agreements but also to declare whether the criteria of article 10 are met by. Iv, issue 8 november 2016 6949 enjoyed by the consumer. Jan 26, 2018 chapter 6 article 103 tfeu regulation regarding the application of arts 101 and 102. Horizontal cooperation agreements may combine different stages of. Consequently, each time it applies articles 5 1 and 6 of the romanian. Chapter 7 article 104 tfeu competence of authorities in member states. Ecj clarifies the scope of standstill obligations in. Article 102 of the treaty on the functioning of the european. Article 102 of the treaty on the functioning of the european union formerly article 82 of the treaty establishing the european community is aimed at preventing undertakings who hold a dominant position in a market from abusing that position.
Merger implementing regulation, the dg competition best practices on the. Furthermore, it remains unclear i whether it is a merger control problem or rather an issue under article 101 tfeu, and ii if it is a merger control issue, whether it should be dealt with when investors acquire minority shareholdings or when portfolio companies merge with competitors. The civil service tribunal to merge with the general court. Chapter 8 article 105 tfeu application of arts 101 and 102 by the commission. The interaction of eu competition, consumer, and data. Apr 23, 2015 competition law webinar article 101 1. Pursuant to article 101 3 of the treaty on the functioning of the european union tfeu, agreements between undertakings that restrict competition within the meaning of article 101 1 tfeu may be declared compatible with the internal market if they contribute to promoting technical or economic progress or to improving the. Agreements that restrict competition by object under article. The office of fair trading oft appears to pursue consumer welfare as chapter is sole goal. United kingdom competition law is affected by both british and european elements. Article 10, or whether there are other ways of reducing potential anticompetitive effects. Article 101 tfeu and market integration pablo ibanez colomo abstract. Thereupon, the separate existence of keepep will cease and texaco will be the surviving corporation and become a wholly.
Article 101 of the treaty on the functioning of the european union prohibits cartels and other agreements that could disrupt free competition in the european economic areas internal market. This means that conduct of the merging parties may breach i the standstill obligation if it contributes to a change of control prior to clearance by the commission, or ii breach article 101 tfeu if it does not lead to a change of control, but nevertheless restricts competition within the internal market. Best practices on the disclosure of information in data rooms in. An overview of the eu competition rules pdf slaughter and may. Ireland, will the two now look to merge and argue in front of the commission that it must accept similar commitments to the ones it has agreed to in ireland. Franchising agreements can be group exempted under the vertical restraints regulation if the necessary conditions are met. Oct 24, 2016 critically discuss how eu law as applied under article 101 tfeu identifies anticompetitive conduct between undertakings, and assess the extent to which such conduct is considered illegal. However, mergers which do not fall within the purpose of the regulation may still breach those articles. Thursday 25 april 10 am tutorial room 7 friday 26 april 11 am tutorial room 10. Article 101 of the treaty on the functioning of the european union. In addition, the european commission may impose a fine pursuant to article 23 of regulation 12003.
Dec 14, 2016 capability vs likelihood in the context of articles 101 and 102 tfeu. Therefore, this merger bringing together the two largest suppliers of signalling systems and very highspeed trains in europe would have significantly impeded competition, prohibited under article 2 of the council regulation 92004 of 2004 7 as interpreted by guidelines on horizontal mergers 8. Larger companies that do a lot of business in the eu cannot merge. May 25, 2015 article 101 tfeu specifies the rules applicable to the behaviour of undertakings. An important distinction exists in the treatment of partial ownership acquisitions between. The following shall be prohibited as incompatible with the internal market. It has always played an important role in eu competition law. Article 101 2 tfeu considers any undertaking found in breach of article 101 tfeu to be null and void and that agreements cannot be legally enforced. Pdf despite the importance of the agreement concept under. Guidelines under scrutiny horizontal mergers and the. Article 101 of the treaty on the functioning of the european union attempts to strike a balance between the need to allow businesses to strike bargains with each other, and the need to ensure that those arrangements do not act against the consumers interests. The tests of illegality under articles 101 and 102 tfeu.
The recent general court gc judgment, case t91, lg electronics, inc. Even after you agree to merge or form a joint venture. Consolidated version of the treaty on the functioning of the european union part three. Article 101 of the tfeu and the equivalent italian legislative provision may affect the terms under which iprs are licensed by acting, for example, to prohibit certain anticompetitive restrictions, unless those terms come under one of the exemptions for which article 10 provides.
The application of eu competition rules in the transport sector itai rabinovici. Companies are not allowed to merge if that would put them in a position to control the market. The general prohibition in article 101 is followed by a nonexhaustive list of examples of anticompetitive practices such as price fixing and market sharing. Consolidated version of the treaty on the functioning of the. The commission gave up its monopoly of applying article 101 3, which. This article will focus on recent developments in the european union and the united states relating to antitrust issues arising from the acquisition of partial ownership interests in an entity. Imagine owning a 50% share of a joint venture that is caught participating in an illegal cartel. According to article 6 of the act, which, as noted above, mirrors article 101 tfeu, agreements, decisions and concerted practices are prohibited if they have as their object or effect the prevention, restriction or distortion of competition on the whole or a part of the dutch market. Commission also found that ici had infringed article 101 by concluding a market. For the purposes set out in article 3 of the treaty on european union, the activities of the member states and the union shall include, as provided in the treaties, the adoption of an economic policy which is based on the close coordination of member states economic policies, on the internal market and on the definition of common objectives, and conducted. Simple facts, but an unclear legislative interpretation leading to inconsistencies in the ecs practice. Irish consumers may also be sceptical as to whether a merger of rivals approved on the basis of the creation of new smaller rivals will get them a. Goals of chapter i of the uks competition act 1998. Article 10 tfeu to justify restrictive practices is.
622 144 334 154 210 713 795 334 1228 340 212 1204 205 1172 41 543 569 1305 89 1119 1535 927 447 656 1297 505 186 348 1505 742 558 245 714 549 1337 5 186 398 1431 1439 27 946 1237